Chapter 5 - The Web of Forgery and Betrayal
The interrogation room at the Benton County Sheriff's Department in Warsaw smelled like old coffee, disinfectant, and fifty years of cheap cigarettes ground into the linoleum.
Mallory was sitting at the metal table, her eyes swollen to the size of plums, her mascara smeared in long, greasy tracks down her cheeks. The oversized sunglasses were gone, replaced by a pair of silver handcuffs securing her left wrist to a welded iron ring in the center of the table.
Detective David Ramos sat across from her, his notebook open, his voice soft and terrifyingly patient.
I sat in the corner, behind the heavy two-way mirror, standing shoulder-to-shoulder with Assistant County Prosecutor Sarah Jenkins.
"Look at this signature, Mallory," Ramos said, sliding an enlarged eight-by-ten photograph across the table. It was the signature line of the Farm Bureau life insurance acceleration request.
Mallory looked away, her throat working in dry, hitched gulps. "I told you. Derek brought me the papers. He told me Claire had signed them before she... before the lake."
"Mallory," Ramos said, leaning forward. "This document is dated August 14th. Claire went into the water on August 2nd. Did she come back from the dead to sign an insurance rider for you?"
"I don't know!" she wailed, banging her free hand against the steel. "Derek said it was legal! He said Marcus Geller handled all the paperwork! I just signed where they told me to sign!"
"You didn't just sign your name, Mallory," Ramos said. He flipped the page. "You signed Claire's name. We have the notary on video from the UPS Store in Clinton. The notary has already identified you. She said you wore a blonde wig and showed her Claire’s old Missouri driver's license—the one reported lost two years ago."
Mallory froze. The weeping stopped instantly, replaced by a deer-in-the-headlights paralysis.
"A blonde wig, Mallory," Ramos repeated softly. "That’s premeditation. That’s identity theft, forgery in the second degree, and attempted grand larceny over twenty-five thousand dollars. In this state, that’s seven to fifteen years in Chillicothe."
"No," she breathed. "No, no, no. I have Noah. Noah is seven! He has asthma! I can't go to prison!"
"Then you stop protecting Derek," Ramos said, his voice hardening like drying concrete. "And you stop protecting Linda. Because right now, Derek is sitting in Jackson County telling the detectives that the entire plan was your idea. He says you were the one who found out about the Farm Bureau umbrella policy."
"He said *what*?!" Mallory shrieked, lunging forward until the chain of the handcuff snapped taut against the iron ring with an ear-splitting ring. "That bastard! That lying, miserable bastard!"
Behind the glass, Sarah Jenkins glanced at me. "She’s breaking."
"She always breaks," I said, my voice dead. "Mallory doesn't have a backbone. She only has appetites."
"He's the one who owed forty grand to those guys in Sedalia!" Mallory screamed, spittle flying from her lips onto the glass. "He came to the house in July! Mom was there! We were sitting in the kitchen, and Derek was crying like a baby! He said they were going to burn his garage down with him inside it! And Mom said... Mom said Claire had more money than she knew what to do with!"
Ramos didn't write anything down. He just kept his eyes locked on hers. "Go on, Mallory."
"Mom said Claire was cold," Mallory sobbed, the words tumbling out in a frantic, incoherent torrent. "Mom said Claire had forgotten who took care of her when Dad died. She said Claire had millions sitting in Kansas City banks while her own flesh and blood were living on food stamps! Derek said the insurance policy was the only way to get it all at once without having to beg her for ten thousand at a time!"
"Whose idea was the lake?" Ramos asked.
The room went dead silent again. Mallory’s breathing was ragged, her chest heaving against her cheap sweater.
"Travis," she whispered.
"Travis?"
"Travis said... he said Claire was too smart. He said if we tried to do a conservatorship while she was alive, she'd hire high-dollar lawyers and tie us up in court for five years. He said... he said people drown in Whitmore every summer. He said the drop-off near the old quarry was eighty feet deep and full of submerged trees. He said once you go down there, the state divers don't even like to go in after you."
Through the glass, I felt the air leave my lungs.
Hearing it described not as an impulsive burst of rage, but as a calculated logistical problem—discussed around my mother’s kitchen table over sweet tea—felt like being dropped back into the freezing water.
"And your mother?" Ramos asked. "What did Linda say when Travis suggested drowning her youngest daughter?"
Mallory swallowed hard. A single tear tracked through the dirt on her cheek.
"Mom said... 'Just make sure she doesn't scream loud enough for the campers on the west shore to hear.'"
Sarah Jenkins let out a slow, sharp breath through her teeth. "Jesus Christ."
"Do you have enough?" I asked, turning to the prosecutor.
"For Mallory? We have enough to bury her," Jenkins said, closing her leather folio. "For Travis and Derek, we have conspiracy to commit first-degree murder. But Linda... Linda is smart. She didn't sign the forged checks. She didn't file the false police report; Derek and Mallory did. Linda’s name is only on the beneficiary designation, which Claire set up years ago."
"My mother doesn't leave fingerprints," I said. "She uses other people’s hands to choke you."
"Then we need something physical," Jenkins said, looking at me with cold, professional sympathy. "Something that ties her directly to the lake that night. Otherwise, her lawyer will claim she was an innocent bystander who was terrified of her nephew and son."
I looked through the glass at Mallory, who had collapsed onto the steel table, her forehead pressed against the cold metal, weeping for herself, for her lost life, for the child she had abandoned to pursue a ghost of easy money.
"I know where the physical evidence is," I said.
Jenkins looked at me, her eyebrows raised. "Where?"
May you like
"In the cedar chest at the foot of my mother’s bed," I said. "My father’s tackle box. She never throws away anything she thinks she can use to control someone."
***
